AI search vs SEO: what is changing and what is not
What Google says about AI Overviews and AI Mode, what studies show about clicks and citations, and what stays the same for SEO. Sources and limits shown.
14 min read
Published by Waqas Nasir
A brand mention is when another site names your company, and a backlink is when it links to you. This post explains what each one does, what the research does and doesn't show, how to earn mentions honestly, and a simple routine for tracking both.
Google says an unlinked mention isn't a link and passes no link signal. A mention can still send readers your way, and one large study found that brand mentions track closely with how often brands appear in AI answers. That study shows correlation, not cause. Ask for links where they help the reader, welcome mentions where you can't get one, and count both.
The two overlap, so it helps to separate them.
A single article can hold all three. A roundup might link to your pricing page, name your product in a comparison table with no link, and call your report "this study" with a link.
Google's own description of links explains why people care. Its guide says it "uses links as a signal when determining the relevancy of pages and to find new pages to crawl." A link is something Google can follow and a reader can click. A plain mention can only be read.
What each one gives you
Linked mention (a backlink)
Unlinked mention
Google has said three things that matter here.
Unlinked mentions are not links. In a Google SEO office hours session on 5 April 2022, John Mueller was asked about articles that mention a site's name without linking to it. As reported by Search Engine Journal, he said: "It's essentially, there is no link, so there is no signal passing like there would be with any normal link there." He added that people may find a site through a mention by searching for it, but that's a different thing from link value.
Links are one signal, and not the biggest. At PubCon in September 2023, Gary Illyes said links are important but "people overestimate their importance," and that they haven't been in the top three ranking factors "for some time." Our guide to the future of link building goes further into that.
Chasing fake mentions isn't helpful. Google's guide to generative AI features (updated July 2026) says its AI features "can show what's being said about products and services across the web, including in blogs, videos, and forum discussions." Then it adds a warning: "seeking inauthentic 'mentions' across the web isn't as helpful as it might seem." It says its core ranking systems focus on high-quality content, while other systems block spam, and that its AI features depend on both.
Notice what Google doesn't say. It doesn't say mentions are a ranking factor, and it doesn't say they're worthless. It says honest ones are fine and manufactured ones aren't worth the effort.
Our view: treat a mention as a business result first and an SEO input second. A mention in the right place puts you in front of buyers, and that's reason enough to want it.
The study everyone cites is from Ahrefs, published 12 December 2025. Ahrefs looked at 75,000 brands and analyzed millions of AI responses to see which factors tracked with how often a brand appeared. It used Spearman correlation, where a higher number means a stronger link between two measures. (We cover the headline numbers in the future of link building and why invest in link building, so we'll be brief here.)
Here's what that doesn't show:
Our view: the sensible takeaway is modest. Being talked about in many places by real people goes together with being named by AI tools. It's a reason to do honest PR, partnerships and community work. It isn't a reason to expect a particular result from any one mention, and nobody can promise you AI citations.
Real mentions come from real activity. Here are the main sources, and what each one needs from you.
The pattern is the same everywhere: someone has a reason to name you.
You can ask for mentions without cheating, and you can cheat without meaning to. These are the rules we'd follow.
Before you ask for a mention
Give the writer something to write about. An answer to a journalist's question, an original number, a clear explanation, a customer story with permission. Our guide to how to reach out to bloggers covers outreach step by step.
Be open about free products and payments. The US Federal Trade Commission's guidance for social media influencers says a "material connection," such as free or discounted products, has to be disclosed when someone endorses a brand, and that disclosures are easy to miss at the end of a post or mixed into hashtags. Google's spam policies also list "sending someone a product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link" as an example of buying links.
Be careful with paid placements. Google's spam policies (updated August 2026) treat links that are bought or sold to pass ranking signals as link spam unless the link is marked rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". A publisher may also label paid content. When we place links for clients, we tell you before you approve a site whether a placement will carry a label, and you decide whether to go ahead. Our guides to rel attributes and buying backlinks explain more.
Don't fake it. Fake reviews, planted forum posts and mass "mentions" on throwaway sites are what Google's AI guide calls inauthentic. Besides being weak, they're exactly what Google's guide says isn't as helpful as it seems.
Tracking mentions doesn't take special software. It takes a short routine you actually keep. Here's a starting point.
| What to count | Where to look | How often |
|---|---|---|
| New linked mentions | Google Search Console Links report, plus referral traffic in your analytics | Monthly |
| New unlinked mentions | Google Alerts for your brand, product and founder names | Check weekly |
| Where each mention sits | Your own sheet: site, page, type of mention, relevance | Monthly |
| Whether it's accurate | Read each mention: name, pricing, claims | When you find it |
| Your pages in Google's AI features | Search Console Generative AI performance report | Quarterly |
| Brand name in AI answers | A short list of prompts you check by hand | Quarterly |
These cadences are our suggestion, not a published standard.
Each tool has limits you should know about:
Here's how a log might look. These entries are invented to show the format.
Count how many fall into each group, not just how many mentions you got. A month with two accurate, relevant mentions beats ten that are wrong or on sites no buyer reads.
If expert quotes are a source of mentions you want to try, see our expert quote link building page for how we run it.
Checked on 6 October 2026.

Tell us your niche and markets. We’ll send a shortlist of sites to choose from.
What Google says about AI Overviews and AI Mode, what studies show about clicks and citations, and what stays the same for SEO. Sources and limits shown.
14 min read
How software buyers research tools, which sites shape the shortlist, and how to earn honest mentions and links there, with sources and a simple method.
8 min read
Which rel attributes matter for links and SEO, what Google says about each one, and the mistakes to avoid. With code examples and sources.
6 min read
Tell us your niche and markets. We’ll send a shortlist of sites to choose from.